Don’t Defund the Police: Do This Instead


Photo of Kevin Donoghue, solicitor, who discusses alternatives to calls to defund the police

Solicitor Kevin Donoghue discusses calls to defund the police and suggests an alternative approach.

By Kevin Donoghue, solicitor

The world has woken up to systemic police abuse with George Floyd’s death.

As I’m sure you know, Mr Floyd, who lived in Minneapolis, USA, was killed by a police officer and helped by his colleagues. The video of his death quickly went viral and spurred a movement based around a controversial idea: defund the police.

Some right-wing commentators are using these calls to suggest that those who demand defunding simply want to:

  1. take money away from policing, and
  2. that they are “soft on crime”.

This false narrative misses the point, and won’t wash in the UK. Here we have our own issues with how the police are currently funded and operate. Many of these factors are caused by years of Conservative government neglect. In effect, we have already defunded the police. So now what do we do?

How the Conservatives Defunded the Police

The Conservative Party likes to call itself “the party of law and order”. But is it? Consider these two contradictions:

  1. On the one hand, since the Tories took charge of government in 2010, they have added numerous criminal laws every year. These varied in purpose from the 2010 Bribery Act to 2019’s Offensive Weapons Act.
  2. But on the other, they have simultaneously de-funded police and enforcement of the law, including legislation the Conservative government itself introduced.

Between 2010-2018 the Tories cut police budgets as part of the austerity measures. Between 2010-2015 alone overall police budgets, excluding counter-terrorism grants, fell by 20%.

These swingeing cuts resulted in 21,732 fewer rank-and-file police officers, or 15% of the total across 43 territorial forces. The “party of law and order” left the country with its lowest number of police officers since 1981.

This dramatic reduction coincided with other things which undermined the police’s role and capacity to fight crime. They included:

  • the increased use of non-qualified police staff at police stations
  • less funding for community-based outreach projects, which act as a link between the police and public and provide vital intelligence on criminal activity
  • increased militarisation and spending on weapons such as Tasers. The firearms, while described by the police as “non-lethal” often result in deaths, causing justifiable outrage and scepticism about the doctrine of policing by consent.

Consequences of Police Defunding

As a solicitor who specialises in civil actions against the police, I believe that defunding the police (together with other factors) has led to misconduct and avoidable errors, causing innocent people to suffer. For example, the police’s unjustified actions have resulted in:

My firm’s clients in the cases described above are all victims of improper police misconduct. They are not just statistics or political footballs: they are innocent members of the public who have been wronged by those tasked to protect them.

Planned Police Budget Increase

In 2019 Boris Johnson became Prime Minister on various pledges, including his own “law and order” campaign. In a move which could define the word “chutzpah” he promised to put 20,000 officers back on the streets, effectively reversing the policies of his own party which, by that point, had governed for nine years. The budget for this is around £500 million in the first year alone.

There is a better way to use that money: spend it on the things we really need.

The other side of the Tory austerity cuts was a de-funding of social care programs. Homelessness, mental health, drugs and alcohol support etc. all suffered as a result. Foodbanks like those in the Trussel Trust Network, were rare 10 years ago. They are now commonplace. Charities like Brunswick Youth and Community Centre have tried to plug community outreach gaps. Sadly, the work of these and other organisations isn’t enough.

And the strain on the police has grown as a result. The police help in times of mental health crises, domestic and social disputes, and countless other areas of public interaction. But police officers are not social workers. Few have qualified experience in managing these often-stressful situations. Inevitably, things go wrong.

Alternative to Police Involvement

The country would be better served if, instead of spending half a billion pounds to recruit 20,000 more police officers, we did the following:

  1. Hire (and train) the same number of social program workers. They could work in existing set ups within local authorities and other organisations. This would be quicker and cheaper than starting from scratch with a new agency.
  2. Get these social program workers to operate as a fully-fledged point of contact for emergency services (999) call operators. Effectively, they would become the fifth emergency service (along with police, ambulance, fire, and coastguard). The simple test would be: does this situation require an armed response? (“Armed” includes Tasers, PAVA/ CS gas, spit hoods, batons etc. and applies to situations where the use of force might be needed.) If it is not immediate obvious to the call operator (e.g. terrorism, armed suspect, immediate threat or use of violence etc.), then they should not send the police and get a social program worker to attend instead. That person can use their discretion to call the police later, but only after they have made a formal determination “on the ground”. This prevents the risk of police involvement without an expert assessment and reduces the chances of things getting out of hand.
  3. Incentivise people to see this kind of work as a valued career. Give them the same good pay and benefits as the police. Recognise and respect their role. Give them every resource to succeed.

Police Role Change

As for the police, they would be freed up from dealing with much of their existing work. They could use their considerable current funding to fight crime instead. I am sure officers would rather do that. It’s what they signed up for, after all.

And if they must become involved in social issues, it is important that the police are fully trained and briefed. When I spoke at a Police Federation conference, I made the point that too many police service calls are treated as criminal justice matters rather than social/ medical/ mental health issues. Officers in the room agreed with me. Redressing this balance with training, understanding, and skill is crucial to the success of policing and its role in society.

Wider Police and Societal Issues

This is only one aspect of a bigger picture:

  • institutional racism in the police
  • inequality
  • punitive government social policies
  • the coronavirus and associated recession
  • many other factors

all play a part.

But it’s a start. It would send a strong message to those seeking real change that the government is listening. After years of neglect, it’s the least it can do.

Kevin Donoghue is a solicitor who specialises in civil actions against the police. Contact him here.